FairwayPal

The FairwayPal Blog

Myrtle Beach vs Pinehurst for a Golf Trip: Which Should You Pick?

May 6, 2026·9 min read

By the FairwayPal Team — built by golfers who've organised too many trips across too many WhatsApp threads.

Last updated: May 6, 2026

Both in the Carolinas, both great golf trips, almost no overlap in what they offer. Myrtle Beach is volume, beach, and the best value in US golf. Pinehurst is heritage, walkability, and the cradle of the American game. Here is the friendly comparison so your group can stop debating and start booking.

Quick Verdict

Choose Myrtle Beach if value matters, partners want beach access, or your group prefers volume of golf and a casual atmosphere. Budget around $900 to $1,500 per person for 3 nights.

Choose Pinehurst if your group wants heritage, walkability, and a more refined village base. Budget around $1,500 to $3,000 per person for 3 nights.

The courses

Myrtle Beach has volume nobody else can match: 100+ courses within 30 miles. Caledonia Golf & Fish Club is genuinely world-class. TPC Myrtle Beach is an excellent test. Pawleys Plantation, Barefoot Resort, and the Dunes Club all rank well. The range is wide: for every Caledonia there are ten budget tracks at $40 to $80. For groups that want to play 4 to 5 rounds in 3 days at varied price points, Myrtle Beach is built for it.

Pinehurst has concentration. Nine resort courses (No. 1 through No. 9) plus The Cradle, all on one walkable property. Pinehurst No. 2 (Donald Ross masterpiece, U.S. Open anchor site for 2024, 2029, 2035, 2041, 2047) is the marquee. Pine Needles, Mid Pines, and Tobacco Road are within 30 minutes off-property. The quality floor is higher than Myrtle Beach; the volume is lower.

Myrtle Beach

  • +100+ courses within 30 miles
  • +Caledonia, TPC, Pawleys are legitimate
  • +$40 to $150 per round typical
  • +More rounds per day possible
  • −Quality range is wide
  • −No single bucket-list course

Pinehurst

  • +Nine resort courses plus The Cradle
  • +No. 2 is a Donald Ross masterpiece + USGA anchor
  • +Pine Needles and Mid Pines nearby
  • +Higher quality floor
  • −Less volume
  • −Marquee No. 2 is $350 to $500/round

The cost

Myrtle Beach is the best-value major US golf destination. Pinehurst is mid-range premium. The gap is meaningful and compounds across a 3-day trip for a group.

Cost ItemMyrtle BeachPinehurst
Marquee course green fee$120 to $180 (Caledonia, TPC)$350 to $500 (No. 2)
Premium course green fee$80 to $150$200 to $350 (No. 4, No. 8)
Value course green fee$40 to $80$80 to $200 (Mid Pines)
Hotel (per room/night)$100 to $200$300 to $600 (Carolina Hotel)
Total per person (3 nights, 4 rounds)$900 to $1,500$1,500 to $3,000

For a 6-person group, the cost difference (~$600 per person) is $3,600 total. Real money. See our golf trip budget guide.

The non-golfer experience

Both work for partners. They suit different partners.

Myrtle Beach is the beach holiday option: 60 miles of Atlantic coastline, the Boardwalk and SkyWheel, Brookgreen Gardens, the Murrells Inlet Marshwalk, Tanger Outlets, casual restaurants. See our Myrtle Beach for non-golfers guide.

Pinehurst is the walkable village option: boutique shops, art galleries, the Tufts Archives golf history museum, the Spa at Pinehurst, Seagrove pottery 30 miles north, Southern Pines for restaurants. See our Pinehurst for non-golfers guide.

Beach lovers go to Myrtle Beach. Village charm lovers go to Pinehurst. Both are good; pick by partner preference.

The vibe

Myrtle Beach is unabashedly fun. Casual, beach-town, family-friendly, and mostly informal. Most groups eat at the Marshwalk, do a Tanger Outlets afternoon, and play 4 to 5 rounds across the trip without much fuss.

Pinehurst is genuinely refined. Southern hospitality, traditional pace, conversations at the bar are about the round. Service is unhurried. The whole village is built around golf history, which is wonderful for a serious-golf group and a little intense for a casual one.

Different trips. Different appetites. Match the vibe to your group.

Three questions that settle it

Is budget a real constraint?

If yes, Myrtle Beach. The $600/person savings across a 6-person group is $3,600 total.

Are partners joining the trip?

Both work, with different appeal. Beach + casual: Myrtle Beach. Refined village + history: Pinehurst.

Are you going for the rounds or for the heritage?

If volume of casual rounds is the goal, Myrtle Beach is unmatched. If the cradle of American golf and the Donald Ross experience matters, only Pinehurst delivers.

Pick a destination. We'll plan the rest.

5 questions. Dual itinerary for golfers and partners. One link the whole group can vote on.

Start Planning

Common Questions

Myrtle Beach vs Pinehurst FAQ

Is Myrtle Beach or Pinehurst better for a golf trip?+
Both great Carolina trips, very different. Myrtle Beach gives volume + beach + value. Pinehurst gives heritage + walkable village. Match to group preference.
Is Myrtle Beach cheaper than Pinehurst?+
Yes, meaningfully. $900-1,500 per person for 3 nights at Myrtle Beach vs $1,500-3,000 at Pinehurst. ~$600 per person gap.
Which is better for non-golfers?+
Myrtle Beach for beach + casual. Pinehurst for refined village + Tufts Archives + Spa at Pinehurst. Pick by partner preference.
Which has more course variety?+
Myrtle Beach by volume (100+ courses). Pinehurst by concentration of quality (9 resort courses plus Pine Needles, Mid Pines).
Which is closer to fly into?+
Both easy. MYR is 5-15 min from Grand Strand hotels. RDU is 70-75 miles from Pinehurst (~80 min). RDU has more nationwide direct connections; MYR is more direct from many Northeast cities in season.

Keep Reading

Related guides

Scottsdale vs Myrtle Beach

The other big Myrtle Beach comparison.

Pinehurst vs Kiawah Island

The two best East Coast golf resorts compared.

Pinehurst vs Pebble Beach

The East Coast versus West Coast bucket-list shootout.

Golf Trip Budget Breakdown

What a golf trip actually costs by destination.

Golf Trips With Non-Golfers

The general playbook for the whole group.

Best Bachelor Golf Destinations

The top six US destinations ranked honestly.