FairwayPal

The FairwayPal Blog

Myrtle Beach vs Kiawah Island for a Golf Trip: Which Should You Pick?

May 6, 2026·9 min read

By the FairwayPal Team — built by golfers who've organised too many trips across too many WhatsApp threads.

Updated

Two destinations on the same Atlantic coast, 130 miles apart, almost no overlap. Myrtle Beach is the most popular value golf trip in America. Kiawah Island is the East Coast bucket-list. If your group is choosing between them, here is the honest comparison.

Quick Verdict

Choose Myrtle Beach if value matters and you want volume of casual rounds, beach access, and a fun unpretentious vibe. Budget around $900 to $1,500 per person for 3 nights.

Choose Kiawah Island if your group wants the Ocean Course on the bucket list, a refined resort experience, and Charleston nearby for partners. Budget around $1,800 to $3,500 per person for 3 nights.

The courses

Myrtle Beach: 100+ courses across 60 miles of the Grand Strand. Caledonia ($120 to $180) is genuinely world-class. TPC Myrtle Beach is an excellent test. The Dunes Club, Pawleys Plantation, and Barefoot Resort all rank well. Wide range from $40 budget tracks to $150+ premium rounds.

Kiawah Island: five resort courses, headlined by Pete Dye's Ocean Course (host of the 2012 and 2021 PGA Championships, with 2031 awarded). Every hole has an ocean view; on a windy day it is one of the most demanding rounds in North America. Cougar Point, Oak Point, Osprey Point, and Turtle Point are the four secondary courses. Less variety than Myrtle Beach, but the Ocean Course alone is a reason to come.

Myrtle Beach

  • +100+ courses, $40 to $150 typical
  • +Caledonia, TPC, Dunes Club legitimate
  • +Volume of casual rounds easy
  • +Very flexible budget
  • −No bucket-list course
  • −Quality range is wide

Kiawah Island

  • +Ocean Course (2012, 2021 PGAs)
  • +Five courses on one private island
  • +Forecaddies enhance the marquee round
  • +Much higher quality floor
  • −Ocean Course is $400 to $600
  • −Less volume than Myrtle Beach

The cost

This is Myrtle Beach's biggest argument. Kiawah is meaningfully more expensive on every line item, especially the Ocean Course green fee and the resort hotel.

Cost ItemMyrtle BeachKiawah Island
Marquee course green fee$120 to $180 (Caledonia, TPC)$400 to $600 (Ocean Course)
Premium course green fee$80 to $150$150 to $280 (secondary courses)
Value course green fee$40 to $80$90 to $150 (Caledonia off-island)
Resort hotel (per room/night)$100 to $200$500 to $1,400 (The Sanctuary)
Forecaddie (marquee round)No$50 to $75 plus tip
Total per person (3 nights, 3 to 4 rounds)$900 to $1,500$1,800 to $3,500

For a 6-person group, that's $5,400 to $12,000 in cost difference. Real money. See our golf trip budget guide.

The non-golfer experience

Both work for partners, very different appeal.

Myrtle Beach is the casual beach-town option: 60 miles of Atlantic beach, the Boardwalk and SkyWheel, Brookgreen Gardens, the Murrells Inlet Marshwalk, Tanger Outlets. Family-friendly, accessible, informal. See our Myrtle Beach for non-golfers guide.

Kiawah Island is the refined resort + Charleston option: 10 miles of Atlantic beach, The Sanctuary spa, kayaking the tidal creeks, biking the maritime forest, and Charleston 25 miles away (one of the best US food cities). More polished, more cultural. See our Kiawah Island for non-golfers guide.

If partners want a beach holiday with shopping, Myrtle Beach. If partners want a refined resort with Charleston culture nearby, Kiawah.

The vibe

Myrtle Beach is unabashedly fun and casual. Bachelor parties, big groups of buddies, beach bars at lunch, the Marshwalk in the evening. The atmosphere is loud, friendly, and unpretentious.

Kiawah is private-island refined. Quiet, gated, expensive, with the rhythm of a destination resort holiday. Other guests are couples and small groups; the noise level is lower; the dress code at dinner is a notch up.

Different trips. Match the group.

Three questions that settle it

Is the Ocean Course on the bucket list?

If yes, only Kiawah delivers. If no, the Caledonia + TPC Myrtle Beach combo is genuinely good for less than half the price.

What is the budget ceiling?

If $1,500 per person is the target, Myrtle Beach. If $3,000+ per person is fine, Kiawah opens up.

Are partners joining?

Either works, different appeal. Beach + casual: Myrtle Beach. Refined resort + Charleston: Kiawah.

Pick a destination. We'll plan the rest.

5 questions. Dual itinerary for golfers and partners. One link the whole group can vote on.

Start Planning

Common Questions

Myrtle Beach vs Kiawah Island FAQ

Is Myrtle Beach or Kiawah Island better for a golf trip?+
Both are South Carolina coast trips, very different feels. Myrtle Beach gives volume (100+ courses), best-in-class value, and a casual beach-town atmosphere. Kiawah Island gives the Ocean Course (host of the 2012 and 2021 PGA Championships, 2031 awarded), a private resort island, world-class spa, and Charleston 25 miles away. If your group prioritises value and volume of golf, pick Myrtle Beach. If your group wants a bucket-list round on the Ocean Course and a more refined resort experience, pick Kiawah.
Is Myrtle Beach cheaper than Kiawah Island?+
Yes, dramatically. The Ocean Course at Kiawah runs $400 to $600 per round plus a forecaddie fee. Myrtle Beach's most expensive courses run $120 to $180. Lodging is also much cheaper in Myrtle Beach ($100 to $200 per night) versus $500 to $1,400 at The Sanctuary at Kiawah. A 3-night per-person trip costs $900 to $1,500 in Myrtle Beach versus $1,800 to $3,500 at Kiawah.
How far apart are Myrtle Beach and Kiawah Island?+
About 130 miles, roughly 2.5 to 3 hours by car along Highway 17. Some groups doing a longer Carolina trip combine both, with Kiawah for the Ocean Course experience and Myrtle Beach for a couple of value-focused rounds. Charleston sits between them and makes a natural stopover.
Which has better non-golf options for partners?+
Kiawah, by a meaningful margin. Kiawah offers The Sanctuary spa, 10 miles of Atlantic beach, kayaking the tidal creeks, biking 30+ miles of maritime forest paths, and Charleston 25 miles away (one of the best mid-sized cities in the US for food, history, and architecture). Myrtle Beach offers 60 miles of beach, Brookgreen Gardens, the Murrells Inlet Marshwalk, Tanger Outlets, and the Boardwalk and SkyWheel. Myrtle Beach is more accessible and family-friendly; Kiawah is more refined and culturally rich.
When is the best time to visit each?+
Both are best March to May and September to November (65 to 80°F, low humidity, courses in beautiful condition). Spring brings azalea and dogwood blooms across the SC coast. Fall brings warm Atlantic water and clear skies. Summer (June to August) is hot and humid (85 to 95°F) and very busy, especially in Myrtle Beach. Winter is mild (50 to 65°F) and quiet, with off-peak pricing at both. Avoid major spring break weeks in March in Myrtle Beach.

Keep Reading

Related guides

Scottsdale vs Myrtle Beach

Two of the most popular US destinations compared.

Myrtle Beach vs Pinehurst

The other big Myrtle Beach Carolina comparison.

Pinehurst vs Kiawah Island

The two best East Coast bucket-list golf resorts.

Kiawah Island Trip Guide

The Ocean Course, four secondary courses, Charleston plan.

Golf Trips With Non-Golfers

The general playbook for the whole group.

Golf Trip Budget Breakdown

What a golf trip actually costs by destination.